RichCafe Consulting Inc.
Tomatin(Speyside) Aggregate View | Scorecard View

Score

Official Bottling

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
84
Tomatin 'Decades' (46%, OB, NAS, 2011*)NAS
46%
2011*
10
84
Tomatin 'C Bcan' (46%, OB, NAS, peated at 15ppm, 2013)NAS
46%
2013
2
87
Tomatin 'Cu Bocan' (46%, OB)NAS
46%
2014
1
85
Tomatin ''Cask Strength Edition'' (57.5%, OB)NAS
57.5%
2015*
1
85
Tomatin 10yo (70 Pr., OB, late 1960s, 75.7cl)10
70 Pr.
1968*
1
81
Tomatin 10yo (43%, OB, +/-1985, Black & gold label)10
43%
1985*
7
77
Tomatin 10yo (40%, OB, +/-1995)10
40%
1995*
6
78
Tomatin 10yo (40%, OB, +/-2005)10
40%
2005
1
0
Tomatin 10yo 1999/2009 (57.1%, OB, Tempranillo Cask Finished, C#29457)10
57.1%
2009
0
82
Tomatin 10yo '"Single Malt Collection"' (40%, OB for Trader Joe's, 2010)10
40%
2010
1
75
Tomatin 12yo 'Scone Palace' (40%, OB for the Earl of Mansfield, +/-2000)12
40%
2000*
3
79
Tomatin 12yo (43%, OB, +/-2000)12
43%
2000*
5
82
Tomatin 12yo (40%, OB, +/-2004)12
40%
2004*
12
80
Tomatin 12yo (40%, OB, +/-2006)12
40%
2006
2
78
Tomatin 12yo (40%, OB, +/-2008)12
40%
2008*
12
77
Tomatin 12yo 'French Oak' (46%, OB)12
46%
2014*
1
86
Tomatin 14yo (46%, OB, Port wood Finish)14
46%
2015*
1
80
Tomatin 15yo (43%, OB, 2009*)15
43%
2009*
11
86
Tomatin 18yo (43%, OB, 2006, 6 months finish in 1st fill Sherry cask)18
43%
2006
4
82
Tomatin 1990/2008 (58.6%, OB, distilled 1990, bottled 12.11.2008, C#16352, 70cl)18*
58.6%
2008
1
80
Tomatin 18yo (40%, OB, +/-2008)18
40%
2008*
12
83
Tomatin 18yo (46%, OB, 2009*)18
46%
2009*
12
85
Tomatin 21yo (52%, OB, C#31648-31654, 2400 Bts., 2010*)21
52%
2010*
8
87
Tomatin 1991/2013 (51%, OB for TSMC - Taiwan, Oloroso Sherry Butt, C#31742, 667 Bts., 700ml)22*
51%
2013
4
87
Tomatin 1991/2013 (51%, OB for TSMC, Oloroso sherry butt, Balance, C#31742, 667 Bts., 700ml)22*
51%
2013
1
85
Tomatin 25yo 1978 (43%, OB, +/-2004)25
43%
2004*
1
82
Tomatin 25yo (43%, OB, +/-2005)25
43%
2005
16
87
Tomatin 25yo (43%, OB, +/-2006)25
43%
2006*
3
84
Tomatin 25yo (40%, OB, +/-2008)25
40%
2008*
11
86
Tomatin 1980/2008 (47.4%, OB, C#994, 172 Bts.)28*
47.4%
2008
2
89
Tomatin 1982/2010 (57%, OB, refill sherry puncheon, decanter, C#92, 560 Bts.)28*
57%
2010
1
87
Tomatin 30yo 1976/2007 (49.3%, OB, 1500 Bts.)30
49.3%
2007
2
85
Tomatin 30yo (46%, OB, 2011*)30
46%
2011*
9
89
Tomatin 1976/2008 (47.2%, OB, C#19090, 107 Bts.)32*
47.2%
2008
1
90
Tomatin 1973/2006 (46%, OB for LMDW, C#25605)33*
46%
2006
6
89
Tomatin 36yo 1973/2010 (44%, OB, refill American oak, decanter, C#25602, 184 Bts.)36
44%
2010
2
88
Tomatin 40yo 1967/2007 (42.9%, OB)40
42.9%
2007
1
83
Tomatin 1967/2008 (49.3%, OB, Germany, refill butt, C#17904, 463 Bts.)41*
49.3%
2008
4

Score

A.D. Rattray

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
87
Tomatin 21yo 1988/2010 (55.2%, A.D. Rattray, Bourbon, D=1 June 1988, B=6 May 2010, C#1088, 213 Bts.)21
55.2%
2010
1

Score

Blackadder

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
78
Tomatin 17yo 1990/2008 (59.1%, Blackadder, C#7716, 275 Bts.)17
59.1%
2008
1

Score

Bladnoch Forum

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
85
Tomatin 16yo 1988/2005 (52.7%, Bladnoch Forum, C#6925)16
52.7%
2005
2

Score

Cadenhead's

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
84
Tomatin 13yo 1976/1990 (60.5%, Cadenhead's, Dumpy, D10/'76 B09/'90)13
60.5%
1990
3
80
Tomatin 17yo 1978/1995 (56.5%, Cadenhead's)17
56.5%
1995
2
81
Tomatin 17yo 1989/2006 (56.4%, Cadenhead's)17
56.4%
2006
2
88
Tomatin 20yo 1976/1997 (46%, Cadenhead's)20
46%
1997
1
91
Tomatin 21yo 1976/1997 (46%, Cadenhead's, 75cl, USA)21
46%
1997
1
87
Tomatin 22yo 1962/1984 (46%, Cadenhead's, Dumpy, Black Label, D05/'62 B07/'84, 75cl)22
46%
1984
3

Score

Celtic Whisky Compagnie

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
87
Tomatin 17yo 1989/2007 (58.6%, Celtic Whisky Compagnie, The Spirit Safe, hogshead, C#4731, 214 Bts.)17
58.6%
2007
1

Score

Chieftain's

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
82
Tomatin 13yo 1996/2010 (50%, Chieftain's, Domina wine finish, C#91582, 327 Bts.)13
50%
2010
2

Score

Clan Denny

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
87
Tomatin 44yo 1967/2012 (51.9%, Clan Denny for The Whisky Fair Limburg, refill butt, C#HH7993)44
51.9%
2012
1

Score

Clydesdale

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
84
Tomatin 18yo 1990/2009 (56.6%, Clydesdale, C#0145/7717, 232 Bts.)18
56.6%
2009
10

Score

Cooper's Choice

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
92
Tomatin 33yo 1967/2000 (43%, Coopers Choice for VA.MA, Sherry, 252 Bts.)33
43%
2000
1

Score

Dewar Rattray

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
88
Tomatin 20yo 1988/2009 (55.4%, A.D. Rattray, C#1087, 203 Bts.)20
55.4%
2009
2

Score

Douglas Laing

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
80
Tomatin 23yo 1976/2000 (50%, Douglas Laing OMC, 186 Bts.)23
50%
2000
2
88
Tomatin 23yo 1976/2000 (50%, Douglas Laing OMC, 293 Bts.)23
50%
2000
2
85
Tomatin 31yo 1975/2007 (55.6%, Douglas Laing Platinum Old & Rare, red wine finish, 252 Bts.)31
55.6%
2007
1
88
Tomatin 32yo 1975/2008 (55.7%, Douglas Laing Platinum Old & Rare, Bourbon cask, 321 Bts.)32
55.7%
2008
3
91
Tomatin 33yo 1967/2000 (50%, Douglas Laing OMC, 594 Bts., D01/'67 B06/'00)33
50%
2000
3
85
Tomatin 36yo 1965/2001 (49.7%, Douglas Laing OMC, 216 Bts.)36
49.7%
2001
3
90
Tomatin 40yo 1963/2003 (42.9%, Douglas Laing Platinum Old & Rare, 197 Bts.)40
42.9%
2003
1
89
Tomatin 40yo 1965/2006 (45.5%, Douglas Laing OMC, 283 Bts.)40
45.5%
2006
3
81
Tomatin 42yo 1965/2006 (43.3%, Douglas Laing Old Malt Cask for Alambic Classique)42
43.3%
2006
1

Score

Duncan Taylor

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
85
Tomatin 33yo 1976/2010 (50.8%, Duncan Taylor Rare Auld, C#6818, 250 Bts.)33
50.8%
2010
2
91
Tomatin 34yo 1976/2011 (51%, Duncan Taylor Rare Auld, refill sherry, C#6822, 301 Bts.)34
51%
2011
2
84
Tomatin 37yo 1965/2002 (48%, Duncan Taylor Peerless, Duncan Taylor Peerless, D01/'65 B12/'02, C#1909, 167 Bts.)37
48%
2002
4
87
Tomatin 41yo 1965/2006 (45.9%, Duncan Taylor, C#1904, 181 Bts., D01/'65 B03/'06)41
45.9%
2006
3
90
Tomatin 42yo 1965/2008 (50.0%, Duncan Taylor Rare Auld, Germany, C#20939)42
50.0%
2008
1
90
Tomatin 42yo 1965/2008 (52.1%, D. Taylor Rare Auld, C#20942, 211 Bts., D11/'65 B01/'08)42
52.1%
2008
4
89
Tomatin 43yo 1965/2008 (52.1%, Duncan Taylor Peerless)43
52.1%
2008
1

Score

Exclusive Malts

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
76
Tomatin 28yo 1976/2005 (51.1%, Exclusive Malts, David Stirk)28
51.1%
2005
2

Score

Gordon & MacPhail

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
84
Tomatin 1968 (40%, G&M Speymalt, late 1980's)NAS
40%
1987*
1
89
Tomatin 15yo 1964 (70 Pr., G&M Connoisseurs Choice, Red/Black Label, Screw Cap)15
70 Pr.
1979*
1
86
Tomatin 1964/1991 (40%, Gordon & MacPhail, Connoisseurs Choice, Old Map Label)27*
40%
1990*
2
88
Tomatin 1964/1994 (40%, G&M Connoisseurs Choice, Old Map Label)30*
40%
1994
1
82
Tomatin 1968/1998 (40%, G&M Connoisseurs Choice)30*
40%
1995*
7
90
Tomatin 1968/2001 (40%, G&M Connoisseurs Choice, New Map Label)33*
40%
2001
3

Score

Hart Brothers

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
88
Tomatin 37yo 1965/2003 (47.2%, Hart Brothers Finest Collection, D11/'65 B05/'03)37
47.2%
2003
5

Score

Jack Wieber

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
89
Tomatin 30yo 1976/2007 (55%, JWWW Old Train Line, C#2601, 273 Bts.)30
55%
2007
3
86
Tomatin 1965/2006 (50.7%, JWWW Cross Hill, 82 Bts.)41*
50.7%
2006
4
90
Tomatin 42yo 1962/2004 (41.7%, JWWW Auld Distillers, 73 Bts.)42
41.7%
2004
1

Score

James MacArthur

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
82
Tomatin 12yo (43%, James Mac Arthur, Painted Pot Still in Mountains Label)12
43%
1995*
1

Score

John Milroy

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
82
Tomatin 33yo 1967/2000 (53.5%, John Milroy, Millennium selection, Sherry)33
53.5%
2000
1

Score

Liquid Sun

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
89
Tomatin 34yo 1976/2011 (48,7%, Liquid Sun, Sherry butt, 366 Bts.)34
48,7%
2011
1

Score

M&H

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
89
Tomatin 40yo 1965/2005 (44.9%, M&H Cask Selection, Bourbon, 120 Bts.)40
44.9%
2005
4

Score

Mackillop's Choice

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
84
Tomatin 25yo 1975/2001 (58.2%, Mackillop's Choice, C#4)25
58.2%
2001
1
69
Tomatin 45yo 1965/2011 (53.5%, Mackillop's Choice, D10/'65, B04/'11, C#19346, 70cl)45
53.5%
2011
1

Score

Maltbarn

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
87
Tomatin 36yo 1976/2012 (50.7%, Maltbarn, sherry butt, 102 Bts.)36
50.7%
2012
1

Score

Malts of Scotland

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
90
Tomatin 1976/2012 (49.2%, Malts of Scotland, Angel's Choice, sherry hogshead, 12046, C#MoS12046, 72 Bts., 35cl)36*
49.2%
2012
2

Score

Master of Malt

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
88
Tomatin 19yo 1989/2008 (57.6%, Master of Malt, bourbon)19
57.6%
2008
1

Score

Moon Import

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
80
Tomatin 1965/1989 (46%, Moon, The Animals, 600 Bts., 75cl)24*
46%
1989
3

Score

Murray McDavid

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
83
Tomatin 1967/2008 (47.7%, Murray McDavid Celtic Heartlands, 523 Bts.)41*
47.7%
2008
1

Score

Scotch Malt Whisky Society

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
80
Tomatin 11yo 1982/1992 (60.4%, SMWS, 11.8)11
60.4%
1992
1
79
Tomatin 12yo 1989 (61.4%, SMWS, 11.24, USA?)12
61.4%
2001*
1
83
Tomatin 16yo 1990/2006 (54.6%, Scotch Malt Whisky Society, 'velvet infinity', 11.27)16
54.6%
2006
2

Score

Scotch Single Malt Circle

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
83
Tomatin 1997/2009 (56.5%, Scotch Single Malt Circle for Weisser, D09/'97 B07/'09, C#4325)12*
56.5%
2009
1
75
Tomatin 13yo (54.7%, SSMC, C#108)13
54.7%
1995*
1
86
Tomatin 1982/2010 (55.3%, Scotch Single Malt Circle, sherry cask, C#29, 574 Bts.)28*
55.3%
2010
11
90
Tomatin 31yo (49.6%, SSMC, Refill Sherry, C#19085, 336 Bts., D22/11/'76 B28/01/'08)31
49.6%
2008
3
87
Tomatin 36yo 1966/2002 (48%, SSMC)36
48%
2002
2

Score

Scott's Selection

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
88
Tomatin 1988/2011 (50.6%, Scott's Selection)23*
50.6%
2011
1

Score

Sestante

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
91
Tomatin 15yo (59.2%, Sestante, mid 1980s)15
59.2%
1985*
2

Score

Signatory Vintage

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
81
Tomatin 12yo 1989/2002 (46%, Signatory UCF, Sherry, C#11642, 864 Bts.)12
46%
2002
2
80
Tomatin 12yo 1991/2003 (46%, Signatory UCF, Sherry)12
46%
2003
1
83
Tomatin 16yo 1989/2006 (46%, Signatory UCF, C#11644, 709 Bts.)16
46%
2006
1
84
Tomatin 18yo 1989/2008 (46%, Signatory Vintage Un-Chillfiltered, Refill Butt, C#11647, 843 Bts.)18
46%
2008
1
90
Tomatin 23yo 1966/1990 (46%, Signatory, Dumpy Old Label, C#9250-53, 1300 Bts.)23
46%
1990
1
87
Tomatin 26yo 1966/1992 (43%, Signatory, C#14362-63, 1200 Bts.)26
43%
1992
1
89
Tomatin 40yo 1967/2007 (51.8%, Signatory, Sherry Butt, C#2632, 415 Bts., D01/'67 B07/'07)40
51.8%
2007
11

Score

The Nectar

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
88
Tomatin 1984/2006 (43%, The Nectar Daily Drams)22*
43%
2006
5
92
Tomatin 34yo 1976/2010 (51%, The Nectar Daily Drams, sherry butt)34
51%
2010
1
90
Tomatin 43yo 1965/2009 'Oat Mint' (47.1%, The Nectar Daily Drams, 210 Bts.)43
47.1%
2009
2

Score

The Ultimate

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
80
Tomatin 18yo 1976/1995 (43%, The Ultimate, Van Wees, C#27636)18
43%
1995
1

Score

The Whisky Agency

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
86
Tomatin 34yo 1976/2011 (51.3%, The Whisky Agency, Refill Sherry Butt, 309 Bts.)34
51.3%
2011
9
90
Tomatin 1976/2011 (51.3%, The Whisky Agency, refill butt, 309 Bts.)35*
51.3%
2011
2
88
Tomatin 35yo 1976/2011 (51.4%, The Whisky Agency, Refill Sherry Wood, "Moody Lion", 313 Bts.)35
51.4%
2011
1

Score

The Whisky Exchange

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
84
Tomatin 30yo 1972/2002 (43%, The Single Malts of Scotland, 444 Bts., D04/'72 B07/'02)30
43%
2002
5

Score

The Whisky Fair

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
84
Tomatin 22yo 1984/2007 (48.1%, The Whisky Fair, The Whisky Fair, Bourbon hogshead, 198 Bts.)22
48.1%
2007
3
83
Tomatin 22yo 1984/2007 (48.9%, The Whisky Fair, Bourbon hogshead)22
48.9%
2007
2
90
Tomatin 30yo 1977/2007 (48.6%, The Whisky Fair, 223 Bts., D02/'77 B02/'07)30
48.6%
2006
8
85
Tomatin 1977/2007 (48,5%, The Whisky Fair, Bourbon, 450 Bts., 70cl)30*
48,5%
2007
1
91
Tomatin 43yo 1965/2009 (48.1%, The Whisky Fair, bourbon hogshead, 120 Bts.)43
48.1%
2009
1
90
Tomatin 45yo 1966/2011 (46.1%, The Whisky Fair, Sherry Butt, 391 Bts.)45
46.1%
2011
1

Score

Whisky Doris

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
89
Tomatin 34yo 1976/2011 (49.5%, Whisky Doris, sherry hogshead, C#9, 139 Bts.)34
49.5%
2011
2
89
Tomatin 43yo 1965/2009 (48.2%, Whisky Doris, refill sherry, C#20950)43
48.2%
2009
4

Score

Whisky-Fssle

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
87
Tomatin 30yo 1977/2007 (48.6%, Whisky-Fssle, bourbon hogshead)30
48.6%
2007
1

Score

Wilson & Morgan

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
77
Tomatin 1989/2002 (46%, Wilson & Morgan, Sherrywood)13*
46%
2002
1

Score

Various Independent Bottlers

Age

ABV

Issued

Ratings
87
Tomatin 1962 (42.6%, V&S Part Nan Angelen)NAS
42.6%
2004*
1
80
Tomatin 12yo 'Blueberrywine finish' (43%, Friends of Malt, 29 Bts.)12
43%
2002*
2
77
Tomatin 12yo 'Applewine finish' (43%, Friends of Malt)12
43%
2002*
2
73
Tomatin 14yo 1989/2004 (57.7%, Norse Cask, Hogshead, C#8383, 257 Bts.)14
57.7%
2004
2
77
Tomatin 16yo 1978 'The Alloway' (57.9%, Various Independent Bottlers, The Whisky Connoisseur, 1994*)16
57.9%
1994*
1
83
Tomatin 19yo 1977/1997 (57.2%, Glenhaven, D09/'77 B06/'97)19
57.2%
1997
6
80
Tomatin 21yo 1968/1990 (40%, Antica Casa Marchesi Spinola, Collection No 1)21
40%
1990
5
81
Tomatin 21yo 1980/2001 (43%, WhiskyWizard, C#4, 378 Bts.)21
43%
2001
1
84
Tomatin 21yo (43%, Culinara, +/-2003)21
43%
2003*
5
79
Tomatin 21yo (43%, Martin's Genuss Ecke, C#7/198)21
43%
2005*
1
84
Tomatin 24yo 1980/2004 (42.7%, WhiskyWizard, C#18147, 306 Bts.)24
42.7%
2004
1
91
Tomatin 25yo 1980/2005 (56.6%, Getranke Weiser, C#13462, 320 Bts.)25
56.6%
2005
5
90
Tomatin 30yo 1975/2005 (55.5%, Various Independent Bottlers, Whisky Wizard, C#19174, 120 Bts.)30
55.5%
2005
1
89
Tomatin 30yo (43%, Classic Cask, +/-2006)30
43%
2006*
1
90
Tomatin 32yo (49.4%, Whiskykanzler, The Uncollectable Collection, 2008)32
49.4%
2008
3
You can find more information about the Tomatin distillery (location, history, equipment, ownership, etc...) on the distillery profile on Malt Madness: http://www.maltmadness.com/whisky/tomatin.html