RichCafe Consulting Inc.

Benrinnes 23yo 1985/2009

(58.8%, OB)
Average Score: 87
Bottle Profile
TypeScotch Single Malts (Disclosed Distilleries)
Bottler Official Bottling
Brand NameBenrinnes
Year Distilled1985
Year Bottled2009
Alcohol By Volume58.8%
Average Score87

Maniac Ratings
Serge Valentin87
Olivier Humbrecht87
Robert Karlsson86
Luca Chichizola88
Oliver Klimek88

WhiskyFun Review

Tasting Notes
Robert KarlssonMalty, muesli, a bit sourly and cooked vegetables. Not too fun. Taste in balance with the nose, some raisin, a bit edgy sourliness at the end. Hm. This one I have tasted before and I enjoyed it much more back then (89p), this time it barely made 80 so I balance the score to 86. Perhaps there are some batch differences or similar but the difference was considerable. Strange..
Oliver KlimekColour: Bright copper - Nose: Prunes, cherries, dark chocolate, polished wood, hints of flintstone and smoke. - Palate: Christmas cake with a cup of strong Earl Grey tea, chocolate mousse with rum-soaked prunes, hints of peppered oxtail soup. - Finish: Long, sweet and fruity. - Overall: Rich, richer, Benrinnes.